Windstop Tests

The full report can be found in MG World, so what you find here is a simple round up of the three top selling wind stops, and we've compared it with not having a windstop. So if you haven't fitted one yet... look at the pictures and make your own mind up!

Me? Well, I have a Mike Satur wind stop, but for you? Check out the figures below and make your own mind up.

Windows Up

 

RV_no_ws.jpg (10528 bytes)

wu-30.jpg (12226 bytes)

wu-70.jpg (12849 bytes)

Drive roof down, windows up,costs you nothing- except time untangling your hair afterwards!!! ;o)

Unobstructed rear view:

*****

30 mph

Wind chill: -3.8oC

Wind noise: 20 dB

70 mph

Wind chill: -5.6oC

Wind noise: 31 dB

 

Driver's window down

 

RV_no_ws.jpg (10528 bytes)

dwd-30.jpg (11186 bytes)

dwd-70.jpg (14219 bytes)

Driving with the drivers window down has been long established as a trick to reduce the buffeting. It costs nothing, and crumbs, it works!

Unobstructed rear view:

*****

30 mph

Wind chill: -4.2oC

Wind noise: 15 dB

70 mph

Wind noise: -4.4oC

Wind noise: 19.5 dB

 

MG windstop

MG_windstop.jpg (12002 bytes)

RV- MG.jpg (10042 bytes)

MG-30.jpg (11928 bytes)

MG-70.jpg (12168 bytes)

Cost £161.00 + VAT

This is the standard fair from MG. You need to drill holes in the T-bar to fit- so removing it is going to leave unsightly holes... oh dear. But it works!

Rear view:

***

30 mph

Wind chill: -1.8oC

Wind noise: 7.5 dB

70 mph

Wind chill: -3.3oC

Wind noise: 12.5 dB

 

Newton Commercial windstop

nc_windstop.jpg (11903 bytes)

RV- NC.jpg (9693 bytes)

nc-30.jpg (10397 bytes)

nc-70.jpg (11314 bytes)

Cost £122.93 + VAT

Hey, it is the cheapest windstop on the market. It doesn't require drilling to fit. Probably the cheapest built here, but it works well, and that counts.

Rear view:

***

30 mph

Wind chill: -2.6oC

Wind noise: 11.3 dB

70 mph

Wind chill: -1.8oC

Wind noise: 20.3 dB

 

Mike Satur windstop

ms-black_windstop.jpg (11364 bytes)

RV- MS.jpg (10565 bytes)

ms-30.jpg (11930 bytes)

ms-70.jpg (11646 bytes)

Cost £225.00 + VAT

Most expensive, but is the best built, best looking, easiest to fit... the list of advantages go on. Mike Satur has improved the mesh design since this test, so expect better high speed performance.

Rear view:

****

30 mph

Wind chill: -4.7 oC

Wind noise: 15 dB

70 mph

Wind chill: -4.4oC

Wind noise: 19.5 dB

 

For the full report, see mgwban.gif (11303 bytes)